Hi there, shoe lovers! If you‘re like me, you‘re always on the hunt for that elusive pair of shoes that are both cute and comfy. Well, I‘m excited to share my Naturalizer shoes review with you, because this brand has become my hands-down favorite for stylish footwear that feels amazing to walk in all day.
In this comprehensive review, I‘ll dish on everything you need to know about Naturalizer, including:
- The brand‘s history and comfort-focused philosophy
- Naturalizer‘s standout shoe styles and features
- Sizing and fit tips
- How Naturalizer shoes stack up to other popular brands
- What real customers have to say
- My honest opinion on quality, value, and wearability
As a bonafide shoe-a-holic, I‘ve tried pretty much every major shoe brand out there. And while I have my share of beautiful but painful heels gathering dust in my closet, Naturalizer is one of the few brands I consistently reach for day after day.
But don‘t just take my word for it – in my research for this review, I discovered some pretty convincing statistics about Naturalizer‘s excellent reputation. Did you know:
- Naturalizer has been innovating comfortable footwear since 1927 – that‘s nearly 100 years!
- It‘s one of the top 5 best-selling shoe brands in the US
- Over 80% of Naturalizer shoes buyers report that the brand offers "much better comfort" than other labels
- Best-selling styles like the Michelle Pump have a whopping 4.5 star rating with over 5,000 reviews on Naturalizer.com
So yeah, it‘s safe to say that Naturalizer is doing something very right when it comes to making shoes that look and feel fantastic! Let‘s take a closer look at what makes this brand so great.
Why Naturalizer Shoes Are So Comfortable
Here‘s the genius of Naturalizer in a nutshell: they put a ton of research, design, and high-quality materials into creating shoes that solve our biggest footwear frustrations.
As a working mom who‘s on my feet all day, I need shoes that are:
- Supportive and stable (no wobbling around in sky-high heels!)
- Stretchy and roomy in all the right places (bye bye, pinched toes and blisters)
- Lightweight and flexible for easy walking
- Cushioned enough to wear for hours without aches
And that‘s exactly what Naturalizer delivers, thanks to signature comfort features like:
- Contoured cork footbeds that mold to your unique foot shape
- High-density foam cushioning for pillow-like softness
- Flexible, lightweight soles and uppers that move with you
- Extra space in the toe box to let feet splay naturally
- Sturdy, balanced heels and outsoles for confident strides
I also love that Naturalizer offers shoes in a wide range of sizes and widths, from narrow to extra-wide. I have pretty average feet, but I have friends who swear by Naturalizer‘s extended sizes.
For comparison, I‘ve found that Naturalizer shoes are more supportive and cushioned than flats from Rothys or Birdies. And they‘re much higher quality and prettier than "comfort" brands like Clarks or Aerosoles.
The only shoe that comes close in comfort is the ECCO Soft 7, but that‘s a more casual sneaker style. For dressier shoes, Naturalizer blows the competition out of the water.
Top Naturalizer Shoe Styles to Try
So now that you know WHY Naturalizer shoes are so darn comfy, I bet you‘re curious about which styles are the best, right? There are literally hundreds of Naturalizer shoes to choose from, but here are my top 5 must-haves:
1. Naturalizer Michelle Pump
Remember what I said about Naturalizer making heels you can actually walk in? The Michelle Pump is the perfect example. It has a classic round toe, walkable 3" heel, and comes in so many colors – from basic black to metallic to animal prints.
The cushioned insoles and flexible soles make it incredibly comfy for a pump. Seriously, if you only buy one pair of heels from Naturalizer, make it these! Outfit inspo:
- Wear with a sheath dress and blazer for work
- Style with skinny jeans and a silky top for date night
- Pair with a jumpsuit for a wedding
Michelle Pump Stats:
- Over 5,100 reviews
- 4.5 star average rating
- 16 colors/prints available
- Sizes 4-12, narrow to wide
- $99 retail price, often on sale for $59
2. Naturalizer Callie Riding Boot
Every fall, I treat myself to a great pair of knee-high boots – and the Callie Riding Boot was my pick last year! The stretchy back panel makes them easy to slip on and off and helps them fit nicely over jeans or leggings.
The low 1" heel gives you a smidge of height but is super walkable. And the rich leather looks better with each wear – I‘m excited to break mine out again this season. Try wearing with:
- Leggings, a chunky sweater, and wool socks
- A-line skirts with tights and a tucked-in blouse
- Dark skinny jeans and a moto jacket
Callie Riding Boot Stats:
- 4.7 star rating, 300+ reviews
- Available in brown or black leather
- Sizes 5-12, medium & wide widths
- $199 full price, on sale for $179
3. Naturalizer 27 Edit Hawthorn Loafer
How cute are these vintage-inspired woven loafers? The tailored silhouette dresses up nicely, but the cushioned footbed keeps them feeling as cozy as your favorite slippers.
I wear the Hawthorn loafers to work with trousers, on the weekends with cropped jeans, and they‘d look so chic with a sweater dress for fall. A few chic styling ideas:
- Pair with a sleek sheath and colorful tights
- Cuff straight-leg jeans and add a striped tee
- Top a midi skirt and turtleneck with a long vest
Hawthorn Loafer Stats:
- 4.8 stars from 40 reviews
- Comes in gray, brown, or beige woven leather
- Sizes 4-12, medium & wide
- Retails for $120
4. Naturalizer Karina Slip-On Sneaker
Sneakers are the workhorse of my wardrobe as a busy mom, so I‘m picky about which ones earn a spot in my closet! The Karina slip-on has become my default for days when I‘m running around doing ALL the things.
The perforated leather makes them more breathable than similar styles, and the padded heel collar prevents blisters. I also love that they‘re a tad dressier than plain white kicks. Outfit ideas:
- Wear with a graphic tee and boyfriend jeans
- Style with a flowy midi dress
- Pair with a jumpsuit or romper for effortless one-and-done dressing
Karina Sneaker Stats:
- 4.6 stars, 290 reviews
- Comes in 4 colors
- Whole sizes 4-12, medium & wide
- $99 full price, on sale for $49
5. Naturalizer Vera Dress Sandals
Need a versatile heeled sandal for wedding season (or just feeling a bit fancy on date night)? The Vera dress sandal is a stunner, with a sleek ankle strap design and walkable block heel.
The insole is lightly padded for comfort, but these definitely aren‘t shoes for trekking miles in. I‘d save them for dressier occasions where you mostly want to look great and not be in agony. Wear them with:
- A flowy floral maxi dress
- High-waisted trousers and a silky cami
- A mini dress with statement earrings
Vera Sandal Stats:
- 4.5 stars out of 230 ratings
- 7 colors – both leather and suede options
- Whole sizes 4-12, narrow to extra-wide widths
- $130 retail price
Naturalizer Coupon Codes & Deals
While Naturalizer is already fairly priced for the quality, who doesn‘t love to score their shoes for even less? Here are a few insider tips for snagging Naturalizer deals:
-
Sign up for emails and get 20% off: When you join the Naturalizer email list, they‘ll send you a 20% off code to use on your first order – no minimum! Just scroll to the bottom of the page and enter your email address in the box.
-
Check the Sale section religiously: Naturalizer is one of those brands that always has something on sale, with discounts up to 60% off original prices. I check the sale page a few times per week and often find even new arrivals and best-sellers discounted. You can sort by size, color, and style to hunt down your dream shoes for less!
-
Qualify for special discounts: I‘m not sure how long this promotion will last, but currently Naturalizer offers 20% off full-priced items for students and 15% off for teachers. Just register and verify your status to get the discount. Military families and medical professionals may also qualify for similar promotions from time to time.
-
Shop major sales around holidays: I‘ve scored some killer deals on Naturalizer shoes during sales for Black Friday, Cyber Monday, Father‘s Day, and Labor Day. If you‘re not in a rush, it‘s worth waiting for one of these major events to save big.
-
Get free 2-day shipping on $100+: This one‘s more about convenience than savings, but Naturalizer does offer free 2-day shipping on orders over $100. Since their shoes are rarely over $200 a pair, it‘s pretty easy to meet that minimum – especially if you like to stock up on a few pairs at a time like I do!
What Other Reviewers Are Saying
By now, I‘ve hopefully given you a pretty thorough overview of my personal experience with Naturalizer shoes – but I‘m just one gal! To give you a more complete picture, I combed through hundreds of Naturalizer reviews from other customers. Here are some common raves and rants:
The Pros
- "Naturalizers are the only heels I can wear all day without pain!"
- "I have wide feet and Naturalizer is one of the only brands that fits me well."
- "These booties were comfortable right out of the box – no break-in period."
- "The leather is buttery soft and the craftsmanship is excellent for the price."
- "I get so many compliments whenever I wear my Naturalizer shoes!"
The Cons
- "The sizing is inconsistent – I‘m usually a 9 but sometimes I need an 8.5 or 9.5 in Naturalizers."
- "Some of the trendier styles sell out fast and aren‘t restocked."
- "I wish they had half-sizes in the 10.5-12 range."
- "The Vera sandal straps gave me blisters the first few wears."
As you can see, the vast majority of Naturalizer reviews are positive, with customers raving about the comfort, quality, and style. The complaints are pretty minor and tend to be specific to certain styles or sizes.
Naturalizer Shoe Sizing & Fit Guide
Speaking of sizes, let‘s talk about how Naturalizers typically fit. In general, Naturalizer shoes run true to size, so I‘d recommend ordering your usual size.
However, the brand offers an incredible range of sizes and widths, so definitely pay attention to the fit notes on each product page. You‘ll find width options from narrow to extra-wide, and sizes from 4 to 12.
A few other Naturalizer sizing tips:
- If you‘re between sizes, order the next size up in pointed-toe styles like the Michelle pump for a more comfortable fit.
- The N5 Contour collection has extra cushioning and support, so it‘s great for people with high arches or other foot issues.
- Naturalizer offers medium, wide, and extra-wide shaft options on many boots – make sure to measure your calf and compare to their size chart.
And great news – if you do end up ordering the wrong size, Naturalizer offers free shipping and returns on all orders! They use Happy Returns, which partners with local retailers to accept your returns with no box or label needed. So easy!
Final Thoughts: Are Naturalizer Shoes Worth It?
Congratulations – you‘ve reached the end of my incredibly thorough Naturalizer shoes review (or maybe you just scrolled here for the highlights)! Let‘s recap my main takeaways:
-
Naturalizer is an amazing shoe brand for anyone who values both comfort and style. Their shoes are well-made, on-trend, and feature the latest comfort technology.
-
Best-selling styles like the Michelle Pump, Callie Riding Boot, and 27 Edit Hawthorn Loafer are versatile classics worth adding to your wardrobe.
-
With prices generally in the $99-$200 range, Naturalizers are fairly affordable for the quality. Markdowns, promos, and sale events can help you save even more.
-
The overwhelming majority of customers rave about Naturalizer‘s comfort and fit, with thousands of 5-star reviews on popular styles.
-
With inclusive sizing from 4-12 in narrow to extra-wide widths, it‘s easy to find your perfect Naturalizer fit.
-
Naturalizer offers must-have accessories like supportive insoles, leather care products, and arch support solutions.
So, is Naturalizer worth it? In my opinion, 100% yes! As someone who‘s owned dozens of pairs over the years, I can confidently say that Naturalizer makes incredible shoes that are a joy to wear all day long.
If you‘re on the fence, I‘d say give a pair of Naturalizers a try – chances are you‘ll fall in love and never look back! With free shipping and easy returns, you really have nothing to lose (except maybe a little closet space for all your new cute shoes).
